an economical referee report for some articles

Sorry about the words below, its too hard to copy them to here, so I attached the requirement document and the articles to be commented!

Arefereereportisacriticalpartofthepeer‐reviewprocessinacademicresearch.Whenanarticleissubmittedtoanacademicjournalforpossiblepublication,theeditorofthejournalsendsoutthepapertoseveralexpertswhoarefamiliarwiththetopicandwhocanevaluatethecontributionsandlimitationsofthesubmittedarticle.Eachrefereewritesareport,whichisthebasisforarecommendationtotheeditoronwhethertoacceptthepaperforpublication,tosuggestthattheauthorsreviseandlaterresubmitthepaperforpublication,ortorejectthepaperforpublication.Sinceeachpaperbelowhasalreadybeenpublished,youdonotneedtoprovidethissummaryrecommendation,butyourreportshouldconsistofallofotheraspectsofarefereereport.Yourreportisintendedfortheauthorsofthepaper.Itshouldbeapproximatelythreedouble‐spacedpagesinlength,anditshouldincludethefollowingparts:2Asummaryofthepaper,whichdiscussesthemainresearchquestion(s),themethodologyusedbytheauthors,andtheconclusionsandcontributionsofthepaper.Adiscussionofwhetherthequestionorquestionsaskedareimportant(ornot)and whether you find the paper convincing or not(andwhy?)Discussion Of The Concerns Havewiththepaper.Theseconcernscouldberelatedtothedatabeingused,theempiricalmethods,sampleselectionissues(do the data seem to be a representative sample?),possiblealternativeexplanationsfortheresultsthattheauthorsdonotconsider(ordo not consider sufficiently),andanyotherweaknessesofthepaper.Finally,arefereereportismeanttobe constructive criticism,so,whenever possible,providepossiblesuggestionsfor improvement.

 

Looking for solution of this Assignment?

WHY CHOOSE US?

We deliver quality original papers	Our experts write quality original papers using academic databases.
Free revisions	We offer our clients multiple free revisions just to ensure you get what you want.
Discounted prices	All our prices are discounted which makes it affordable to you. Use code FIRST15 to get your discount
100% originality	We deliver papers that are written from scratch to deliver 100% originality. Our papers are free from plagiarism and NO similarity
On-time delivery	We will deliver your paper on time even on short notice or  short deadline, overnight essay or even an urgent essay